Return to Discussion Group
Should We Limit Smartphone Access for Children?
In May we’ll be discussing Should We Limit Smartphone Access to Children?
Across the world, momentum is building to restrict children’s use of smartphones and social media. Parents, educators, and child‑health advocates argue that constant connectivity may undermine wellbeing, learning, and healthy development.
Several governments have already banned mobile phones in schools, while some are exploring wider limits on children’s access to social platforms. Technology companies have resisted these measures, denying responsibility for alleged harms in a series of legal challenges.
In the UK, the government is reviewing its approach, with a school‑day phone ban planned in the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill.
What are the facts? What evidence is there that use of smart phones and social media harm children? Are the proposed measures proportionate to the risk? Or are they more likely to be counterproductive?
Books
Podcasts
Internet
Humanists in Berkshire: Are Social Media Damaging Teenage Mental Health? By Roger Hepplston
NBC News: Are smartphones harmful to youth mental health? Experts torn on Jonathan Haidt’s book
Nature: The great rewiring: is social media really behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?
LSE Review of Books: Is social media behind the decline in youth mental health?
Scientific American: Should schools limit kids’ screen time? The science is murky
After Babel | Jon Haidt | Substack
5 Rights Foundation – Building the digital world that young people deserve
BBC News: Meta told to pay $375m for misleading users over child safety
The Conversation: Landmark lawsuit finds that social media addiction is a feature, not a bug
After Babel: The Case Against Social Media: Seven Lines of Evidence
Wired Parents: Social media bans for children by country | Live tracker 2026
WSWGfL: Why a Social Media Ban for Under-16s Isn’t the Right Answer

